Still reviewing the Katrina thing, and how it was/is being handled by the different groups that must work on recovering from an event like this, and tending to the victims, I have, as usual, a few more comments. I bring these to table based on my experience, which I'm not touting as anything special, just noting it so you can see where I'm coming from. I am a volunteer fireman, and as such have some training by FEMA on something called ICS (Incident Command System). ICS teaches you how to lead the efforts needed to deal with a disaster. I'm a person who has spent significant amounts of his life in 3rd world countries, where disasters of large magnitude are a lot more common than they are here, and whose effects are usually huge and spread through time. Minor disasters in such places don't even make the 1st page of local newspapers, since they're so common. And resources to deal with them are pitiable. Last but not least, the Gods saw fit to give me more than the usual share of common sense, which probably explains why so many people utterly lack it. My theory is that there was only so much to go around.
So, putting on my 3rd world denizen hat, I've seen a lot of disasters in my time, and most people in those countries are very used to them. That's why Fatalism as a philosophy is so common outside the industrialized West, they are literally used to dying in droves if anything goes even slightly wrong. Bad crop, extreme weather, nasty geological processes, war, you name it. Part of the outrage that a lot of Americans are pouring out right now against FEMA, the President and other organizations stems from not being used to large-scale disasters, for one, and more important
ly, being completely unable to grasp the magnitude of what happened in Louisiana. People think the TV gives a good idea of how things are. People, it doesn't come even close. I'm not even going to try and explain it here, since I can't come close, either. You just have to be in one. I will provide a
linked map that brings up photos of the areas affected. Browse through them, if you will, and come back here, so we can continue my monologue. If you get a chance, look through
these, too.
Hopefully, you'll have looked at a few pics. And I'm sure there are easily worse pics available, from earlier in the tragedy. I've a feeling those show areas after waters receded a bit. I went through 2 floods in the town I live in within the past year. Nothing big as disasters go, just the main street flooded up to chest height, prompting us to close down that section of town and evacuate the residents to our Fire Station. Check the archives here for
September of '04 if you want the story, and a pic or two. Still, that was huge for the residents affected, who lost a lot of their property. Twice, mind you. But throughout we had power, we had open roads (except for the one we closed), we had communications, and we had order. You lose all that when a large area is flattened and/or isolated in such a way that bringing in people, supplies and equipment from outside the affected area is well nigh impossible. It's so easy from a place of comfort to write that the government should have predicted it (they did) and should have prevented it (they can't). Sure, errors were made, again, mainly because we as a people haven't a clue what a real disaster is. We should train in places where disasters are an everyday occurrence. Tsunamis look very different when one's coming straight at you than they do on CNN.
Should people have been evacuated? Hell, yeah! Problem is logistics, and democracy. Let's start with that last one. It's damned if you do, and damned if you don't. If Bush, or the Governor, or the Mayor had ordered an evacuation before the fact, everybody would have been up in arms about the government's attempt at abrogating more power than it should have and pointing out what a dictatorship we live in. Since that didn't happen, the complaints center around why we didn't take everybody out, by force if necessary. As for logistics, let's suppose you did start to force people out. You'd need a hell of a lot more resources than you have in order to carry that out if people aren't willing. The first time our town flooded, back in September, folks didn't evacuate despite our going door to door requesting they get out. Second time around, in April, they didn't need any prodding. We said evacuate and they left a vapor trail getting out. People do learn. Unfortunately, they often learn the hard way. And to top it off, they'll forget too quickly.
Yet another camp is bitching about all the planes we have in Iraq, and why those aren't available for operations in New Orleans. Well, folks, those plains aren't made to land on waterlogged houses and brief islands amid the swamp. They're good at bombing, though. Is that what you want them used for in New Orleans?
Curiously enough, the effects of a Class 4 on New Orleans had been predicted some time back. Check out the predictions
here. Uncanny, huh? You'll find similar predictions, though, on most any conceivable disaster. There's people paid exclusively to come up with these scenarios. The downside is you can't protect for every possible scenario, ever. Not enough resources in the world to do that for every place inhabited by humans. Shit happens in our Universe, it's just the way it is. You protect what's feasible, and hope for the best, even while knowing the worst will happen, every now and then.
A good friend forwarded me an
article today, or yesterday, regarding some of the looters being firemen and policemen. Big surprise. I have news for all of you. A lot of arsonists are firemen. They start fires and then have fun putting them out. And a lot of cops are crooked. I'll wait till you come out of the faint you're in by now, since this must come as a huge surprise.
Sad thing is that most police and fire departments know full well which of their members would be better off being policed rather than policing. But political correctness, anti-discriminatory laws gone amok and union action bordering on the other side of insane keep them at work. Try firing a cop or a fireman short of having a newspaper slap a picture of them committing some outrageous act and you'll be dragged into courts, and disciplinary hearings and a ton of other shit because people today are more enamored of the letter of the law rather than its purpose. You'd think a union would be the first to recognize that a bad apple must be discarded, but no, they're just interested in proving that a union's power is great. Also, bear in mind that no matter how good a police or fire department vets its members, even fantasizing that political correctness and its offshoots have taken a flying fuck into the lake, the cops and firemen will still be human, and prone to humanity's issues. You want perfection, you've got a long wait ahead of you.
So what you end up with is the situation we have right now. Huge mess, caused not by the government, nor by FEMA, nor even by a clueless Mayor. It was caused by a hurricane. The aftermath could, arguably, have been handled slightly better, but not by much. It really wouldn't have helped a whole lot if you had a million people ready to rush in as rescuers, and a billion tons of supplies for them to take in, if at the end of the day you had no good way of getting all that inside the affected area.
Disasters happen, and people are going to continue dying in them. Sucks to be on the receiving end of it, I know, since I've been lucky enough to live through several disasters. You pick up, you rebuild, you move on, and hopefully, you learn a bit. For example, there's no way I'd ever consider buying a house on a certain street in my town, since that street has flooded twice in 6 months. A few weeks ago an auction sold two houses there for very low prices. Had I not known what I know, I'd have probably been suckered into buying one of them, either for personal use, or as an investment. Now I know better.
Next time around, I'm sure FEMA and everyone else are going to be better prepared to deal with something like this. That doesn't help the victims of Katrina, but it will undoubtedly help the victims of the next disaster.
For now, go and
donate blood or money. Instead of whining about how horrible the response to the disaster has been, go and try to help out.